Alpha
All entriesContact
Model

Luciole 1.1 Instruct

Publisher
LINAGORA SAS, within the OpenLLM-France consortium (FR)
Family
Luciole
Openness
open_weights_recipe
Licence
Apache License 2.0 (declared in card metadata and the card licence section; no LICENSE file in the Instruct repos)
Context
131k (base window; post-trained on 16,384-token sequences)

You own the use of the weights. Apache-2.0 is declared, the repos are ungated and your data stays on your hardware. Training code and both datasets are public, so most of what the model is can be inspected. You cannot rely on its safety, because no safety evaluation or guard model exists. The level rises when a safety evaluation, a LICENSE file in the Instruct repos and a technical report are published.

Do you really own it?
Partial
none·limited·partial·substantial·full
Analytical input: AOI D · 51.2/100
The four ownership factors

Floor-weighted, not averaged. Reliability is weak, and the weakest factor sets the ceiling, so the verdict stays partial however strong the rest.

1

Use and modify freelyCan you run, modify and adapt it with no gate and no field-of-use trap?

Strong

Apache-2.0 is declared for the Instruct weights, which are ungated and fine-tunable, with commercial use allowed. The Instruct repos have no LICENSE file, and LINAGORA SAS is named as owner in the NOTICE file (ev-card-instruct, ev-notice).

How this scores (AOI sub-dimensions)
Openness4/5how much is released - weights, data, code, licence - and how freelyWeights, training and evaluation code, the pretraining corpus and the post-training data are public under Apache-2.0 for the weights, which fits the weights-plus-recipe anchor.
Legal3/5how permissive and clean the licence is for real commercial useApache-2.0 is declared and LINAGORA SAS is named as owner in the NOTICE file.
2

TransparencyDo you know what it is: weights, training, behaviour, and legible terms?

Strong

Weights, training and evaluation code, the pretraining corpus and the post-training data are public, and the cards are detailed. Gaps are the unpublished technical report and the external server for three web subsets (ev-pretrain-data, ev-posttrain-data, ev-code-repo).

How this scores (AOI sub-dimensions)
Provenance2/5how well we can trace and verify what went into the modelSafetensors only, a clean Hugging Face scan, LFS hashes and one canonical source give about 4 of 8 checklist boxes.
Governance3/5how accountable and well-documented the publisher isLINAGORA SAS is a named company, the project has Bpifrance funding and GENCI compute, and releases came in February, July, September, October and November 2026.
3

ReliabilityIs it reliable and good enough for the job?

Weak

Operational readiness is 3, and safety is 1 because no safety evaluation, guard model or acceptable-use policy is published. The Thinking card states that safety alignment can still leave unsafe output (ev-card-instruct, ev-card-thinking).

How this scores (AOI sub-dimensions)
Operational3/5how practical it is to run, serve and maintain in productionvLLM, Ollama and llama.cpp routes are documented, with official GGUF and FP8 builds.
Safety1/5whether misuse risks are evaluated and guardrails are providedThe Instruct card has no safety section, no acceptable-use policy and no guard model.
4

Doesn't extract your dataDoes running it keep your knowledge and data yours?

Strong

The weights run on your own hardware under Apache-2.0 with no clawback clause. The 23B repo ships only safetensors, tokenizer and configuration files, with no loader code (ev-card-instruct, ev-hf-platform).

How this scores
Not a scored AOI dimension. For a self-hosted model, data-control is a structural property of running the weights yourself, strong by default unless the model phones home or the licence claws back rights. For a hosted API this factor is the retention + train-on-inputs + residency read, scored from the binding terms.

How the AOI score is computed

The seven dimensions above, each scored 0 to 5, weighted and summed to the 0 to 100 headline. The score is the analytical input behind the ownership verdict, not the verdict itself.

DimensionScoreWeightPoints
Openness4/50.1814.4
Provenance2/50.166.4
Legal3/50.169.6
Safety1/50.163.2
Performance2/50.145.6
Operational3/50.127.2
Governance3/50.084.8
HeadlineD · 51.2/100
Dossier coverageAssess 87%Implement 86%Use 72%Support 44%How complete our four-domain documentation is, a measure of our coverage, not of the model. Each domain links to its page.

Sources

Every rating traces to a primary document. Read means the text was verified; unverified means it is known to exist but has not yet been read.

DocumentWhat it grounds
Model cardread2026-11-19
The 23B Instruct card declares Apache-2.0 and names LINAGORA SAS as copyright holder.
Model cardread2026-11-19
The Thinking-1.1 card opens with a note that the model 'has undergone safety alignment during the DPO thinking phase' and can still produce unsafe output.
Model cardread2026-11-19
The Luciole-23B-Base card declares Apache-2.0 and lists French, English, Italian, German, Spanish, Portuguese, Dutch and Arabic with token shares.
Licenceread2026-11-19
The Base repos contain a LICENSE.md holding the full Apache License 2.0 text with the template front matter and an unfilled 'Copyright [yyyy] [name of copyright owner]' line.
Licenceread2026-11-19
The NOTICE file of the Luciole-Training repository says the Luciole models, including Instruct-1.1 in all three sizes, are the property of LINAGORA SAS and released under Apache-2.0.
Licenceread2026-11-19
The LICENSE file of the Luciole-Training repository is the standard GNU General Public License version 3 text.
Documentationread2026-11-19
The Luciole-Training repository has 532 commits and holds data processing, tokenizer training, NeMo pretraining, conversion, NeMo and NeMo-RL fine-tuning folders and a lighteval-based evaluation folder.
Documentationread2026-11-19
The OpenLLM-France organisation is not verified on Hugging Face, has 20 members and lists 38 model repos.
Documentationread2026-11-19
Luciole-PostTraining-Dataset-1.1 is public and ungated under CC-BY-SA-4.0.
Documentationread2026-11-19
Luciole-Training-Dataset is public and ungated under CC-BY-SA-4.0, with per-source licences listed.
Model cardread2026-11-19
The 8B and 1B Instruct cards match the 23B card.
Technical_reportunverified2026-11-19
No Luciole technical report exists.
Model cardread2026-11-19
The benchmark figure on the 23B Instruct repo, made by the publisher, compares Luciole with Gaperon-1125-24B-SFT, EuroLLM-22B-Instruct-2512 and two Mistral-Small-24B models.
Vendor announcementread2026-11-19
The consortium site calls the project 'totalement open source', says it is funded by Bpifrance for two years with nine partners, and says it republishes training datasets.
Documentationread2026-11-19
The Nemotron-Instruction-Following-Chat-v1 card says its data came from GPT-OSS-120B and Qwen3-235B and is CC-BY-4.0.
Documentationread2026-11-19
RedTeachingBench is a French false-premise benchmark with 1,000 prompts for teachers using LLMs, under CC-BY-SA-4.0.