Model
Boldt-DC
Publisher
Chair of Machine Learning, Humboldt-Universitaet zu Berlin (Alan Akbik; authors Ansar Aynetdinov and Patrick Haller) (Germany)
Licence
Apache License 2.0 (declared in card metadata only; no LICENSE file in the repos and no licence text in the card bodies)
You own the use of the weights: Apache-2.0 is declared, ungated, commercial use is allowed and your data stays on your hardware. You do not own a deployable German assistant, because these are small base models with no safety evaluation, you cannot rebuild them without the unreleased training code, and every benchmark is the publisher's own. The level rises if the group ships a LICENSE file, releases its training code and configs, and settles the Llama 3.3 question on the classifiers.
Do you really own it?
Partial
none·limited·partial·substantial·full
Analytical input: AOI D · 45.2/100
The four ownership factors
Floor-weighted, not averaged. Reliability is weak, and the weakest factor sets the ceiling, so the verdict stays partial however strong the rest.
1
Use and modify freelyCan you run, modify and adapt it with no gate and no field-of-use trap?
StrongApache-2.0 is declared on both cards, ungated, with weights downloadable and the exact training dataset public; caveat: no LICENSE file ships and the Llama 3.3 question on the classifier chain is open (ev-licence, ev-llama-terms).
How this scores (AOI sub-dimensions)
Openness3/5how much is released - weights, data, code, licence - and how freelyOpen weights, a public training dataset (the 28B-token Dense-Core subset), public filter classifiers, a thorough paper and cards, and an Apache-2.0 declaration put it at the top of the open-weights anchor.
Legal3/5how permissive and clean the licence is for real commercial useThe declared licence is Apache-2.0, ungated, which is clear for common uses, and the paper and dataset card document corpus, filter recipe and upstream licences (ODC-By and Common Crawl terms).
2
TransparencyDo you know what it is: weights, training, behaviour, and legible terms?
ModerateWeights, training dataset, filter classifiers and a detailed paper are public, but training code, configs, the label set and an evaluation harness are not, so the models cannot be rebuilt exactly (ev-paper, ev-dataset).
How this scores (AOI sub-dimensions)
Provenance2/5how well we can trace and verify what went into the modelSafetensors only, Hugging Face LFS hashes, a scan that flagged nothing and plain Llama-architecture files with no custom code give about 4 of 8 checklist boxes.
Governance3/5how accountable and well-documented the publisher isAn accountable university chair with named authors, a peer-reviewed paper (EMNLP 2026), a project page, two release batches (May and August 2026) and README edits as late as 2026-11-01.
3
ReliabilityIs it reliable and good enough for the job?
WeakSafety is 1 (no safety evaluation, stated by the publisher) and operational readiness is 2 (transformers sample only, no quantised builds or hardware guidance); these are base models, not deployable assistants (ev-card-1b, ev-paper).
How this scores (AOI sub-dimensions)
Operational2/5how practical it is to run, serve and maintain in productionThe weights are standard safetensors with a plain Llama architecture and load through transformers (the cards show only that route).
Safety1/5whether misuse risks are evaluated and guardrails are providedThese are base models and say so; the cards and the paper state plainly that no toxicity, bias or stereotype evaluation was done and that repeated epochs may amplify biases.
4
Doesn't extract your dataDoes running it keep your knowledge and data yours?
StrongSelf-hosted weights under a declared Apache-2.0 licence with no clawback clause, standard Llama architecture files and no custom code in the repos (ev-licence, ev-hf-platform).
How this scores
Not a scored AOI dimension. For a self-hosted model, data-control is a structural property of running the weights yourself, strong by default unless the model phones home or the licence claws back rights. For a hosted API this factor is the retention + train-on-inputs + residency read, scored from the binding terms.
How the AOI score is computed
The seven dimensions above, each scored 0 to 5, weighted and summed to the 0 to 100 headline. The score is the analytical input behind the ownership verdict, not the verdict itself.
DimensionScoreWeightPoints
Openness3/50.1810.8
Provenance2/50.166.4
Legal3/50.169.6
Safety1/50.163.2
Performance2/50.145.6
Operational2/50.124.8
Governance3/50.084.8
HeadlineD · 45.2/100
Sources
Every rating traces to a primary document. Read means the text was verified; unverified means it is known to exist but has not yet been read.
DocumentWhat it grounds
Model cardread2026-11-19
The Boldt-DC-350M card declares Apache-2.0 in its metadata only, says the Boldt series is 'trained from scratch' (a publisher claim), calls the model a base model not optimised for chat, and says no systematic toxicity, bias or stereotype evaluation was done.
Model cardread2026-11-19
The Boldt-DC-1B card declares Apache-2.0 in its metadata only, gives a 2,048-token context and 200B training tokens of the German Dense-Core subset, reports a 44.05 average on the publisher's German benchmark suite, and carries the same no-safety-evaluation statement.
Licenceread2026-11-19
Both repos declare 'license: apache-2.0' in front matter and are not gated.
Technical_reportread2026-11-19
The EMNLP 2026 paper 'Repetition over Diversity' (arXiv 2604.28075, Aynetdinov, Haller and Akbik, Humboldt-Universitaet zu Berlin) describes training models 'from scratch' on filtered German FineWeb-2.
Documentationread2026-11-19
Boldt/fineweb2-de-dc is a public ODC-By 1.0 dataset of 24.4M German documents (28B tokens) subject to Common Crawl's Terms of Use, selected by three released classifiers trained on Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct labels; the classifier repos have no README, no licence and no LICENSE file.
Terms of serviceread2026-11-19
Llama 3.3 Community License section 1.b.i says that anyone who uses Llama Materials or any outputs of them to train or improve a distributed AI model shall include 'Llama' at the beginning of that model's name.
Documentationread2026-11-19
The Boldt organisation is not verified on Hugging Face and has two members.
Model cardread2026-11-19
Sibling releases differ from the DC models.
Vendor announcementread2026-11-19
The Hugging Face organisation README and the project page name the Chair of Machine Learning at Humboldt-Universitaet zu Berlin as the developer and describe Boldt as 'state-of-the-art' and 'top-tier'; these are marketing statements.
Third-party analysisread2026-11-19
No independent benchmark, leaderboard entry or safety report for any Boldt model was found; the only outside artefacts are community fine-tunes on the Hugging Face Hub.